Protection · Virtual lab · Intermediate · about 18 minutes
GFCI, AFCI, Overload and Short Circuit: Which Device Responds
A breaker, a GFCI and an AFCI all open a circuit, and each one is blind to the faults the others catch. Take both devices apart below, then run a shock, a leak, an overload, a short and two kinds of arcing through the circuit and predict, before each run, which device opens.
You will learn:
- The four faults: overload, short circuit, ground fault and arc fault, and which element sees each one
- How a GFCI compares hot and neutral current and opens on a few milliamps of difference
- What a combination AFCI looks for in the shape of the current
- Why a GFCI receptacle still needs the breaker in the panel
- The trip times behind each device, from the same curves the simulator runs
- What none of these devices can see, and why the model is simpler than the real thing
What this model assumes
- The ground-fault sensor is a pure comparison of hot and neutral current with a 5 mA threshold, the nominal value inside the 4 to 6 mA band a Class A device must honor, and its trip time follows the UL 943 curve T = (20 ÷ I)^1.43 seconds with a floor of 25 ms.
- Arc detection is modelled as a range check: a series arc of 5 A or more, or a parallel arc of 75 A peak or more (about 53 A RMS), is detected and the device opens within half a second. Real devices analyze the current's signature and differ by manufacturer.
- Thermal and magnetic behaviour follows the panel lesson's curve: never at or below the rating, an inverse-time delay above it, about one cycle at ten times the rating.
- Each scenario is a fixed set of RMS currents. A person is a fixed current of 30 mA, and every reading is the instant before a device opens.
Four faults, three kinds of protection
Everything that goes wrong on a branch circuit lands in one of four bins. An overload is too much current through the normal path: a heater and a microwave on one 20 A circuit, drawing 24 A together for ten minutes. A short circuit is current taking a path with almost no resistance, hot to neutral or hot to hot, so the service pushes a thousand amps or more through it. A ground fault is current leaving the circuit by a path it should never use: through the metal case of an appliance, through a damp wall, through a person standing on the ground. An arc fault is current jumping a gap in a damaged cord or a loose connection, sputtering, making heat where there is no load to use it.
The ordinary breaker from the panel lesson answers the first two. Its thermal element, a bimetal strip, bends as the current warms it and trips an overload after minutes. Its magnetic element, a coil around the current path, pulls the latch open in about one cycle when the current passes roughly ten times the rating. Both elements read one thing only: how much current is flowing. A 30 mA shock is 0.15 percent of a 20 A rating, and a sputtering arc leaves the average current where it was, so the breaker sees nothing wrong in either.
A GFCI, a ground-fault circuit interrupter, reads something different. Both the hot and the neutral pass through one sensing coil. In a healthy circuit every milliamp that leaves on the hot returns on the neutral, and the two cancel inside the coil. When 5 mA goes missing, because it is returning through a person or a wet case, the coil sees the difference and the device opens in a fraction of a second. A Class A GFCI must trip between 4 and 6 mA, far below the current that hurts.
An AFCI, an arc-fault circuit interrupter, reads the shape of the current rather than its size. Arcing current is ragged: it starts late in each half cycle, has sharp shoulders and carries high-frequency noise. The electronics in a combination AFCI look for that signature in two forms, a series arc in a loose connection carrying the load current, and a parallel arc between hot and neutral in a damaged cord, and open the circuit before the arc has time to start a fire.
| Fault | What a breaker's elements see | What a GFCI sees | What an AFCI sees |
|---|---|---|---|
| Overload, 24 A on 20 A | Thermal element: trips after minutes | Nothing: hot and neutral still match | Nothing: no arc |
| Short circuit, hot to neutral | Magnetic element: trips in a cycle | Nothing: the current returns on the neutral | Nothing: no arc |
| Ground fault, 30 mA through a person | Nothing: 0.15 percent of the rating | A 30 mA imbalance: trips in about half a second | Nothing: no arc |
| Arc fault in a cord | Nothing: the average current is normal | Nothing: hot and neutral still match | The arc signature: trips within half a second |
Take them apart
The drawing below opens a GFCI receptacle and an AFCI breaker side by side. Switch to the exploded view to spread the pieces, and tap any piece, or its name in the list, to see what it does and how it fails.
Interactive: Inside a GFCI receptacle and an AFCI breaker
Two pieces explain most of what a GFCI does. The sensing coil is a small current transformer with both the hot and the neutral threaded through its window. Equal and opposite currents make no net field, so the coil's output is zero until some current leaves by another path. The test button closes a resistor from the load side of the hot to the line side of the neutral, around the coil, which creates a deliberate imbalance of a few milliamps. If the electronics and the solenoid are working, the device trips; if it does not trip, it is finished and gets replaced.
An AFCI breaker looks like an ordinary breaker with a circuit board added. It keeps the bimetal and the magnetic coil, adds the arc detection board that reads the current through a small sensor, and carries a neutral pigtail, the white lead that lands on the neutral bar. The pigtail powers the electronics and gives them the neutral current to compare, and the circuit's own neutral lands on the breaker's load neutral terminal instead of the bar. Forgetting that pigtail, or landing the circuit neutral on the bar, is the most common reason a new AFCI or GFCI breaker trips the moment it is switched on.
Predict before you run
The simulator in the next section runs a shock, a leak, an overload, a short circuit and two kinds of arcing through one 120 V circuit with the device of your choice at the panel or the outlet. Commit to two predictions first.
Predict first
A 2 A lamp is running on a 20 A circuit with an ordinary breaker. Someone standing on a damp floor touches a hot part and 30 mA flows through them to the ground. What opens?
- The breaker, on its magnetic element
- The breaker, on its thermal element, after a few minutes
- Nothing opens, and the 30 mA keeps flowing
- The main breaker
What happens
The hot now carries 2.03 A, about 10 percent of the rating. The thermal element never warms and the magnetic element never notices. Only a device that compares hot with neutral sees the 30 mA that left the circuit, and a GFCI opens on it in about half a second. Try it: pick the person scenario with the standard breaker, run it, then switch to the GFCI breaker and run it again.
Predict first
A kitchen counter circuit has a 20 A breaker in the panel and a GFCI receptacle on the counter. A heater and a microwave plugged into the GFCI draw 24 A together for ten minutes. Which device opens?
- The GFCI receptacle, at once
- The breaker in the panel, on its thermal element, after several minutes
- Both at the same moment
- Neither, because 24 A is close to 20 A
What happens
A GFCI receptacle compares currents and has no overcurrent element. 24 A leaves on the hot and 24 A returns on the neutral, so the receptacle sees nothing wrong. The 20 A breaker in the panel carries the overload and its thermal element opens after about seven minutes on the lesson's curve. Try it: pick the overload scenario with the GFCI receptacle and watch which of the two devices in the drawing opens.
Run the circuit
Choose a device, choose a scenario, say whether you think the device opens, and run it. The sequence shows the fault appearing, what each element sees, and the outcome with the element that acted and its time. Readings show the hot and neutral currents, the difference between them in milliamps and any arcing current. Pick the GFCI receptacle and the drawing shows two devices at once, the receptacle and the ordinary breaker ahead of it.
Interactive: One circuit, six devices, ten faults
How fast a GFCI opens on 30 mA
Given: Class A trip curve: T = (20 ÷ I)^1.43 seconds, with I in milliamps; 30 mA through a person
- 20 ÷ 30 = 0.667
- 0.667^1.43 = 0.56
Answer: About 0.56 s, long before the shock becomes dangerous
How long a breaker carries 24 A
Given: 20 A breaker on the lesson's curve: time = 180 ÷ (m² − 1) seconds, where m is the multiple of the rating; 24 A, so m = 1.2
- m² − 1 = 1.44 − 1 = 0.44
- 180 ÷ 0.44 = 409 s
Answer: About 7 minutes on the thermal element
| Scenario | Standard breaker | GFCI breaker | AFCI breaker | GFCI receptacle |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| Normal load, 12 A | Holds | Holds | Holds | Holds |
| Person to ground, 30 mA | Holds | Opens (ground fault, 0.56 s) | Holds | Opens (ground fault, 0.56 s) |
| Person hot to neutral, 30 mA | Holds | Holds | Holds | Holds |
| Damp appliance, 8 mA | Holds | Opens (ground fault, 3.7 s) | Holds | Opens (ground fault, 3.7 s) |
| Overload, 24 A for 10 min | Opens (thermal, 7 min) | Opens (thermal, 7 min) | Opens (thermal, 7 min) | Holds |
| Bolted short, 1,500 A | Opens (magnetic, one cycle) | Opens (magnetic, one cycle) | Opens (magnetic, one cycle) | Holds |
| Parallel arc, 60 A arcing | Holds | Holds | Opens (arc, 0.5 s) | Holds |
| Series arc, 6 A | Holds | Holds | Opens (arc, 0.5 s) | Holds |
| Neutral to ground, 20 mA | Holds | Opens (ground fault, 1 s) | Holds | Opens (ground fault, 1 s) |
| Hot to grounded case, 600 A | Opens (magnetic, one cycle) | Opens (magnetic, one cycle) | Opens (magnetic, one cycle) | Opens (ground fault, 0.025 s) |
Three things worth trying. Run the person scenario with every device in turn: only the devices with a ground-fault sensor open, and the standard breaker lets the 30 mA flow for as long as the person is there. Then run the person who is between hot and neutral with no ground path: nothing opens, because every milliamp comes back on the neutral and the imbalance is zero. Finally run the hot-to-case fault with the GFCI receptacle and the standard breaker ahead of it: both see the fault, and the magnetic element wins by a few milliseconds. A dual-function breaker does whatever the GFCI breaker or the AFCI breaker would do, whichever is faster.
What the model leaves out
- Arc detection is signature analysis. The model checks whether an arc is inside a range. A real combination AFCI compares the current's waveform against patterns of series and parallel arcing and ignores the look-alikes it has been taught, such as brush motors and dimmers. How well it does that differs by manufacturer and by model year.
- The threshold is a band. A Class A device must not trip below 4 mA and must trip at 6 mA. The model's 5 mA is the nominal value. A damp day can put a long outdoor circuit's leakage near the band, which is one reason an outdoor GFCI trips when it rains.
- No device sees hot-to-neutral contact through a person. The currents balance, the magnitude is tiny, and there is no arc.
- Self-test and end of life. Devices made since 2015 test themselves and lock out or indicate when they fail. The model's devices never age.
- Trip times are nominal. Real devices trip anywhere inside their published bands, and the lesson's breaker curve is a smooth stand-in for a manufacturer's time-current curve.
- Load-side protection. A GFCI receptacle protects itself and the receptacles wired to its load terminals. A GFCI breaker protects the whole circuit, wiring included. The model shows one receptacle and one appliance.
Name the device, name the cause
Three challenges on the same drawings and the same model. Each one checks your answer at once.
Challenge: Find the part
The lesson names a part of the GFCI receptacle or the AFCI breaker, such as the sensing coil or the neutral pigtail, and you find it on the drawing or pick it from the list.
Challenge: Which devices open?
Five scenarios: a person touching a hot part, an overload, a bolted short, a neutral-to-ground contact and a series arc. For each one, pick every device that opens on its own: standard breaker, GFCI breaker, AFCI breaker, dual-function breaker, GFCI receptacle.
Challenge: Name the cause
Three service calls: a GFCI receptacle that trips the moment it is reset with nothing plugged in, an AFCI that trips when an old vacuum starts, and a 20 A breaker that trips ten minutes after a heater and a microwave are both switched on. Pick the cause.
One habit carries through all three. A device that trips is reporting something: an overloaded circuit, a leaking appliance, a damaged cord, a miswired neutral. Find the cause before resetting, and never replace a GFCI or an AFCI with an ordinary device to stop a trip. The protection was required there for a reason, and the fault it found is still there.
Where this work shows up
Kitchens, bathrooms, garages, basements, laundry rooms and everything outdoors call for ground-fault protection, and most living areas call for arc-fault protection, so a residential electrician installs and tests these devices on nearly every job. Remodels and panel upgrades bring the replacement rule into play: a receptacle swapped in a location that now needs protection has to provide it, which turns a simple device change into a GFCI or a dual-function breaker.
Service calls are where the four faults become diagnosis. A GFCI that will not reset points at moisture, a leaking appliance or a neutral touching ground on the load side. An AFCI that trips at night points at a damaged cord, a loose connection or a load whose brush arcing looks like a fault to an older device. A breaker that trips after minutes points at an overload, and one that trips the instant it is reset points at a short or a bolted ground fault. Reading the device tells you which bin the problem is in before the first meter reading.
The same ideas scale up. Ground-fault protection of equipment on large services, residual current devices in IEC countries, and the arc-flash work in industrial plants all rest on the same two questions: how much current is flowing, and is it coming back the way it left. If this is the kind of work you want more of, the openings below are residential and service roles where these devices are daily business.
Check your understanding
1. What does a GFCI measure to decide whether to trip?
Answer: The difference between the hot and neutral currents. Both conductors pass through one sensing coil, which reads the difference. A Class A device trips between 4 and 6 mA of imbalance, 5 mA in the model.
2. Someone on a damp floor touches a hot part on a 20 A circuit with an ordinary breaker, and 30 mA flows through them. What does the breaker do?
Answer: Nothing: 30 mA is far below its rating. The hot carries about 2.03 A, roughly 10 percent of the rating. The breaker reads only the size of the current and sees a normal load, so the 30 mA keeps flowing until the person lets go or a GFCI opens.
3. A heater and a microwave draw 24 A for ten minutes on a 20 A circuit that ends in a GFCI receptacle. What happens?
Answer: The breaker in the panel trips on its thermal element after about seven minutes. A GFCI receptacle has no overcurrent element and the currents balance, so it stays closed. The breaker carries the 120 percent overload and its thermal element opens after about seven minutes on the lesson's curve.
4. A nail joins hot to neutral and 1,500 A flows on a circuit with a GFCI breaker. Which element opens it?
Answer: The magnetic element, in about one cycle. Every amp returns on the neutral, so the sensor sees balance. 1,500 A is 75 times the rating, far above the magnetic pickup, and the magnetic element the GFCI breaker still carries opens in about a cycle.
5. A loose terminal arcs in series with a 6 A lamp load. Which device opens?
Answer: A combination AFCI, on its arc-fault detector. The current never rises above 6 A and all of it returns on the neutral, so thermal, magnetic and ground-fault elements see nothing. The AFCI reads the arc's signature and opens within half a second in the model.
Where this knowledge gets used
- Residential openings: GFCI and AFCI requirements shape kitchen, bath, garage and bedroom circuits on every house and every remodel.
- Service and repair openings: The GFCI that will not reset and the AFCI that trips at night are everyday service calls.
- Working as a journeyman: What journeyman electricians are expected to know and how the role grows.
Sources and further reading
UL Standards and Engagement
UL 943, Standard for Ground-Fault Circuit-InterruptersThe Class A 4 to 6 mA threshold and the trip-time curve the simulator uses.
United States and Canada. Current edition as listed by UL.
NEMA (AFCI Safety)
AFCI Safety: arc-fault circuit interrupters explainedHow combination AFCIs detect series and parallel arcing.
United States. Current site.
US Occupational Safety and Health Administration
Electrical, Safety and Health TopicsGround-fault protection on job sites and the hazards it addresses.
United States. Current topic page.
National Fire Protection Association
NFPA 70, National Electrical Code (NEC)Sections 210.8 and 210.12 locations and the 406.4(D) replacement rule.
United States; adopted by jurisdiction. 2026 edition issued August 2025; the 2023, 2020 and 2017 editions remain in force in many states; each state adopts its own edition and amendments.
CDC, National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health
Electrical Safety in the WorkplaceThe effects of shock current on the body, which set the bands in the simulator.
United States. Page dated February 14, 2024.
Lessons are free study material. Finishing one does not certify a skill, count toward a license or replace hands-on training under qualified supervision.